Why Engineering Teams Get Estimation Wrong (and How to Fix It)

Ask any engineering team about their biggest headaches, and you'll hear a common theme: getting estimates right is a constant struggle. When estimates miss the mark, the effects cascade. Developers burn out trying to meet impossible deadlines, features ship late, and the tension between engineering and business teams rises.

Getting better at estimation isn't just about improving your prediction skills. Today's engineering teams juggle complex codebases, navigate unexpected technical hurdles, manage service dependencies, and coordinate across time zones. While these realities make estimation feel like guesswork, many teams have found solid footing by thoughtfully applying Agile frameworks and ceremonies to their planning process.

In this blog, we’ll identify the core problems behind poor estimation, explore how Agile methodologies provide solutions, and outline actionable steps engineering teams can take to improve their estimation accuracy.

3 Common Causes of Poor Estimation

1. Frequent Requirement Changes

Nowadays, product priorities shift due to changing market conditions or evolving customer needs. While this flexibility can be beneficial, it can also damage planning and estimation.

• Shifting priorities: When teams are midway through a sprint and receive new requirements, this can disrupt timelines, force rework, and often derail progress.

• Lack of clarity: Vague or incomplete requirements at the start of a sprint make accurate estimation nearly impossible. Late-stage changes compound the problem, reducing productivity and increasing frustration.

To mitigate this, teams need mechanisms to adapt quickly without compromising their timelines, a challenge that Agile frameworks address.

2. Difficulty in Estimation

Engineering projects are inherently complex to estimate for several reasons:

• Unpredictability: The complexity of software development tasks often hides unforeseen challenges.

• Dependencies: Many tasks rely on other systems, teams, or external resources, which can introduce delays.

• Cognitive bias: Teams may be overconfident or too optimistic in their estimates, underestimating time and effort.

• Lack of historical data: Without tracking past performance, teams lack the context to make informed predictions.

These factors make estimation a mix of science and art—an area where structured estimation techniques can help reduce guesswork.

3. Sprint Scope Creep

Scope creep occurs when additional tasks or changes sneak into a sprint without proper planning. It’s a productivity killer that leads to missed deadlines and overburdened teams.

Triggers of scope creep:

• Unclear boundaries for sprint goals.

• Stakeholder pressure to add “just one more feature.”

• Poorly defined acceptance criteria.

Scope creep often signals a lack of discipline in adhering to Agile principles. Therefore, teams must address this issue to improve their estimation accuracy.

How Agile Frameworks Tackle Estimation Challenges

Agile methodologies like Scrum provide a structured approach to address estimation issues. Here’s how they can help your team:

Breaking Work into Manageable Units

Agile emphasizes breaking down large projects into smaller, manageable pieces:

• User stories, epics, and tasks: Dividing work into smaller units clarifies requirements and makes estimation easier.

• Iterative delivery: By focusing on incremental value delivery, teams can adjust estimates and priorities as new information becomes available.

This approach minimizes the impact of shifting requirements and helps teams stay on track.

When used effectively, these ceremonies instill discipline and foster a culture of continuous learning, helping teams improve their estimation accuracy over time.

4 Practical Steps to Improve Estimation in Engineering Teams

1. Leverage Data from Past Sprints

Learning from the past is one of the most effective ways to improve estimation.

• Track metrics such as velocity, burn-down charts, and historical performance to understand how much work your team can realistically complete in a sprint and facilitate effective planning.

• Use this data to create a baseline for future estimates and identify patterns or bottlenecks.

2. Use Estimation Techniques

Agile provides several estimation techniques to balance accuracy with efficiency:

• Planning Poker: Encourages team collaboration and consensus, reducing the impact of individual bias.

• T-Shirt Sizing: Quickly assigns relative sizes (e.g., small, medium, large) to tasks, ideal for high-level estimates.

• Three-Point Estimation: Considers optimistic, pessimistic, and realistic scenarios to provide a balanced estimate.

Experimenting with these techniques can help teams find the right fit for their needs.

3. Define Clear Sprint Goals and Boundaries

To avoid scope creep and misaligned priorities:

• Align on priorities and acceptance criteria: Ensure everyone understands the “Definition of Done” before starting a sprint.

• Set boundaries: Clearly define what’s in scope and what isn’t. Use Agile tools to track and communicate progress transparently.

4. Foster Better Communication in Remote/Hybrid Teams

Communication gaps are a common challenge in remote or hybrid setups. To address this:

• Centralize information: Use collaboration tools like Jira, or Trello to keep everyone aligned.

• Asynchronous discussions: Tools like Slack or Microsoft Teams allow team members to collaborate effectively across time zones.

• Promote shared understanding: Encourage frequent check-ins to clarify tasks and expectations.

When teams communicate effectively, they can address ambiguities early, reducing the likelihood of estimation errors.

Takeaway

Poor estimation hurts engineering teams by causing delays, burnout, and strained stakeholder relationships. However, leveraging Agile frameworks, ceremonies, and estimation techniques allows teams to address these challenges and improve their estimation accuracy systematically.

Improve your team’s estimation skills with Team O’Clock’s Agile tools for sprint management and estimation. Sign up for a free 15-day trial today and set your engineering team up for success!